Monthly Monthly Review Review (March 2026)
Here are some short excerpts and annotations from what I’ve been reading–the March 2026 issue of Monthly Review. For funner content about our recent travels, see some of the videos Porscha recently uploaded to YouTube.
Vijay Prashad, Could Capitalism Have Thrived Without Colonialism?
I listened to the same Jacobin podcast episode featuring Vivek Chibber that this article takes down. It was awful and I won’t link to it here. It was so bad that I couldn’t stop thinking about how bad it was for a whole week. I’m glad to see Prashad’s article expose Chibber’s snakish attempt to separate anti-colonialism from anti-capitalism.
“The argument is not that capitalism could not have emerged in any conceivable world without colonialism, but that capitalism as it historically emerged—industrial, global, racialized, and imperial—was inseparable from colonial expropriation.”
Shoutout to unequal exchange: “[Jason Hickel and his team] calculate that the Global North drained $18.4 trillion through the unequal exchange process (or the global labor arbitrage) in 2021 alone—not including all the more direct ways in which surplus is siphoned off from the Global South.”
Excellent explanation of the role of primitive (originary) accumulation in colonialism and capitalism:
“Originary accumulation must be understood as a violent reorganization of social reproduction, not merely as the expropriation of land and the coercive mobilization of labor for commodity production. Colonial capitalism systematically dismantled subsistence economies, communal land use, and kinship-based systems of care, thereby forcing the reproduction of labor power onto increasingly precarious and feminized forms of unpaid or underpaid work. In the colonies, women’s labor—food production, care work, water and fuel collection, child-rearing, and the maintenance of displaced communities—became an unacknowledged subsidy to imperial accumulation. This was not incidental to capitalist development but constitutive of it. The plantation, the mine, and the monocrop economy could only function because the costs of reproducing labor were violently externalized onto colonized households and, within them, onto women. Originary accumulation thus entailed not only the separation of producers from the means of production, but the separation of social reproduction from collective control, subordinating it to the imperatives of imperial markets, debt regimes, and racialized patriarchy. This destruction and reorganization of social reproduction remain among the most enduring and least acknowledged mechanisms through which primitive accumulation continues to operate in the Global South.”
“imperialism is not an outgrowth of capitalism, but is foundational to capitalism itself”
The importance of rejecting Chibber’s lies: “To deny this is not simply to misread history, it is to disarm Marxism politically. A theory that severs capitalism from imperialism cannot account for the persistence of unequal development, racialized labor, and ongoing forms of primitive accumulation. A Marxism adequate to our world must therefore begin where capitalism itself began—not only in the English countryside, but in the plantation, the mine, the colony, and the machine.”
Chris Gilbert, Global South Struggles for Socialism and the Workers' Side of Marxism
On the differential adaptation of the workers’ side of Marxism to the Global North and the Global South:
“On the one hand, workers of the Global North tend toward greater subjection to capital and tend to be more fully instrumentalized by it: this comes close to incarnating the expectations of the “one-sided Marxism” that adopts the perspective of capital. On the other hand, the working peoples of the Global South are typically less fully integrated into the logic of capital, while they confront the most bald and violent contradictions of the capitalist-imperialist system. This leads the working class of the Global South to pursue radical alternatives and express their agency more fully.”
On the idea that “socialism will not arise before capitalism has run its historical course” and the identification of that transition point (another tie-in to unequal exchange):
“Moreover, even a cursory examination of capitalism’s trajectory over the past century undermines the notion that capitalism possesses an objective limit that can be identified in advance on the basis of purely economic criteria. That trajectory demonstrates how what have often appeared to be objective limits to capitalist development in the Global North have repeatedly been transformed into temporary barriers, that are overcome through a variety of “fixes.” A central mechanism in this process is the transfer of imperial and colonial surpluses from the peripheral to the core countries. These surpluses contribute to, among other things, the continual expansion of socially conditioned needs for a large swath of the Northern working class, generating what Marx called “golden chains” that bind them to the system. If that is the case, how and where will it be determined that the productive forces have been completely exhausted under capitalist social relations such that those relations are transformed into insurmountable “fetters”?” (The answer is the social process of class struggle, not an objective economic calculation.)
“the level of economic development needed to initiate a process of socialist construction turns greatly on workers’ consciousness of the need for socialism to replace capitalism at least as a strategic goal
“Golden” chains vs. “far more brutal and materially real” chains:
“workers in dependent countries are bound by chains far more brutal and materially real than the “golden chains” that tie workers in the Global North to the imperial mode of life.”
On why actual socialism has always begun in the periphery, not the core:
“the real-world option for socialism begins not just anywhere in the globe but in the countries of dependent capitalism—capitalism in the colonial and neocolonial condition—for it is in these national contexts that capitalism’s fundamental inability to satisfy working people’s needs becomes evident first. It is the Global South’s workers, within the frameworks of their respective nations, who will recognize that no capitalist-oriented trajectory will result in “catching up” but will instead drive their societies to social ruin and underdevelopment, along with environmental destruction.”
The “Abstract Proletariat” may be useful for theory, but the revolutionary subject or the concrete proletariat should be more broadly defined to include “the diverse mass of toilers in Global South countries,” even if they aren’t wage workers and haven’t yet been proletarianized according to theoretical models.
Also see the quote from Paul Sweezy at the end of Gilbert’s article:
“If we consider capitalism as a global system, which is the only correct procedure, we see that it is divided into a handful of exploiting countries, and a much more numerous and populous group of exploited countries. The masses in these exploited dependencies constitute a force in the global capitalist system which is revolutionary in the same sense and for the same reasons that [Karl] Marx considered the proletariat of the early period of modern industry to be revolutionary. And finally, world history since the Second World War proves that this revolutionary force is really capable of waging successful revolutionary struggles against capitalist domination.”
Comments
Post a Comment