The Hills Were Alive: Capitalist Suppression of Agroecology

Review of Communism: the Highest Stage of Ecology by Guillaume Suing (Iskra, 2025)

Cuba is one of the few countries in the world whose forest area is larger than it was 50 years ago, and its forests are still growing. A couple of years ago, Porscha and I visited a community a few hours outside of Havana called Las Terrazas. On our visit, we saw people socially and ecologically reconnected through sustainable agriculture. Our guide (an agroecological scientist moonlighting as a tour guide), Leonardo, was a boy in one of the first families who moved to Las Terrazas in the late 1960s or early 1970s. He personally worked on planting the tens of thousands of trees that now cover the hillsides where he led us hiking and around the community where he lives.


Las Terrazas in December 2023


In the 1800s, Las Terrazas had been completely deforested by French slavers who had fled the Haitian Revolution to restart their slavery-coffee businesses. Coffee monoculture ruined the land for decades after the French left. Within a decade after the Cuban Revolution, the government started an agroecological project to transform Las Terrazas and build a sustainable community there. The transformation is incredible. The community now includes thousands of acres of trees, just a half-century old but forming a diverse and quickly maturing ecosystem surrounding small farming plots. We enjoyed birdwatching in the traces of the former coffee plantations. The community is home to almost 1,000 residents who raise animals, grow crops, plant trees, host tourists, produce art, teach students, run a library and a clinic, and otherwise tend to the needs of their community and ecosystem. Las Terrazas is all organic–no chemical fertilizers or pesticides–and a wonderful small-scale model of what socialist governance can accomplish through planned development.


Toward the end of Torkil Lauesen’s Unequal Exchange (reviewed here and here), there is a brief discussion of ecological unequal exchange: the asymmetrical transfer of environmental goods and energy from the Global South to North and of environmental harms from the Global North to South. The North has outsourced industrial production to the South and industrial pollution along with it. China produces more goods for the North than any other country but the pollution that comes with that production mostly stays in China (and is blamed on China by many Northerners). Ecological unequal exchange internationalizes the class dynamics of environmental degradation, which is disproportionately suffered by the poor and working classes within a nation and is likewise disproportionately suffered by the poorer nations. It’s the manifestation of the metabolic rift under capitalism: the disruption of natural systems by removing elements faster than they can be replenished or by adding pollutants faster than they can be absorbed. As the metabolic rift disrupts natural life-sustaining cycles, we try to bridge the rift with increasingly complicated scaffolding. We try to replace the natural sources of soil fertility with chemical fertilizers, to replace natural predators and weed suppressants with pesticides, to replace the soil itself with imports from afar, to seed the clouds and sterilize the soil. But each such workaround creates more problems than it solves and can only postpone nature’s revenge–the piling-up of small disruptions that spell large-scale catastrophe and extinction.


Reading about the metabolic rift in Monthly Review and its international aspect in Lauesen’s Unequal Exchange, alongside my longstanding fascination with trees, stirred my interest in ecosocialism. I found just the scratch for that itch in Guillaume Suing’s Communism: the Highest Stage of Ecology, a 2018 book that Iskra published in English in 2025, available for free online. The book hasn’t lost any relevance since 2018. It provides a crucial assessment of agroecological contradictions under capitalism, an historical assessment of socialist agroecology and sustainable development, and an intriguing examination of socialist philosophy and the science of epigenetics.


Ecology, Agriculture, Sovereignty, and Life


"[I]t is imperialism that is currently blocking all funding for thorium-based molten-salt reactors, even though these are risk-free, because they would compromise the military-industrial nuclear weapons lobby with which the uranium circuit has been linked for decades. It's also agribusiness that has always blocked research into agroforestry, because it would give people greater national sovereignty and remove the limits to soil fertility that underpin Western agricultural monopolies."


Agricultural self-sufficiency and resilience protects a people from dependency and vulnerability that generate moments of crisis, which “the imperialist West sees [as] more opportunities for extraction and exploitation.” Suing quotes Henry Kissinger on the terrible position of needing food aid from the North and the chains that come with it: "To give food aid to a country just because they are starving is a pretty weak reason." Moreover, ecological vulnerability fuels unequal exchange (ecological and economic), which sustains the whole capitalist imperialist system. There is significant overlap between ecological unequal exchange and classic/economic unequal exchange, as capitalism tends to exhaust both nature and labor, the sources of all wealth. As Suing observes, "capitalism's over-exploitation of the soil since the Second World War is reminiscent of the over-exploitation of the 'invisible' colonial peoples, providing a Western labor aristocracy with the crumbs it needs to purposely nurture social peace in the heart of the metropolis."


More broadly, an understanding of the natural environment of which we are part–and how our mode of production interacts with it–is key to human life itself. We must understand how the alteration of soil fertility under capitalist agriculture leads to dead ends. Contra Malthus, the problem isn't overpopulation or rising living standards in the South, but the global capitalist system. We can't go back to pre-capitalist modes of production. We need to build a new mode of production with a technical revolution that only a socialist system can plan, and we can learn from the often-overlooked agricultural experience and development of socialist countries like the Soviet Union and Cuba.


Capitalist Agriculture and the Metabolic Rift


"The wealth of the capitalist system is...wasted, lost in the deep pockets of big business and financial tycoons. It only contributes to the major collective investments advocated by the scientific community when the context urgently requires it, and when it's usually already too late. The anarchy of production that characterizes the system prevents any democratic planning on major common issues, and it should be obvious to environmental activists that social and ecological progress cannot be envisaged without at the same time unblocking technical progress."


The capitalist system is incapable of whole-system management because of its focus on near-term profit and its disregard of external costs and time-delayed effects. For capitalist agriculture, this means the destruction of soil fertility–as Marx wrote: "All progress in increasing the fertility of the soil for a given time is a progress towards ruining the more long-lasting sources of that fertility." 150 years before ecosocialism was a thing, Engels wrote about how the focus of individuals on immediate profits destroyed the foundation for production: "What cared the Spanish planters in Cuba, who burned down forests on the slopes of the mountains and obtained from the ashes sufficient fertilizer for one generation of very highly profitable coffee trees -- what cared they that the heavy tropical rainfall afterwards washed away the unprotected upper stratum of the soil, leaving behind only bare rock!" Under capitalism, a business that turns a profit in one season by destroying the soil will outcompete and attract more investment than its neighbors who refrain from soil destruction and need five years to implement sustainable agriculture.


Capitalists disregard not only the negative externalities of soil degradation, but also the positive externalities of centrally planned investment in sustainable agriculture. As French journalist Francis Cohen wrote in 1950 in defense of Soviet agroecology: "What good would agrobiology do for the American trusts? What's the point of scientific research that improves the soil from year to year, when it is more advantageous, in order to cut costs, to engage in forced cultivation that destroys and exhausts the soil, turning millions of square kilometers of arable land into deserts?” This is why, in our capitalism-dominated world, most agriculture is now dependent on fertilizers and pesticides. Soil is treated as a commodity to be converted into money. Capital is mobile but the land is not. When soil is exhausted of its ability to naturally sustain life, capital can move on to the next fertile field or try to synthesize fertility through sterilizing and polluting chemicals that support a very narrow range of life and kill the rest. Sustainable agriculture is more expensive and can't immediately compete in the market with non-organic food commodities. "It takes years to obtain rich agricultural soils that can be destroyed in a short time," so why not leave the costly and time-consuming process of soil development to someone else? Farmers are pressured to extract life from the soil at a rate faster than it can be replenished. This is the capitalism-driven metabolic rift.


Because the ecological rift emerges from the same basic economic rift–the alienation of workers from their own production–mending the first rift requires mending the other. The economic rift is directly traceable to the pitfalls of capitalist agriculture: "reducing farmers' rights to resow their own seeds, tightening the conditions for variety recognition by small independent entrepreneurs, and restricting the circulation and exchange of seeds between associations and growers.” Under capitalism, planned obsolescence has even reached seeds! Rather than finding natural and self-sustaining sources of resilience and adaptability in plants, capital has hijacked agrobiology in favor of genetically modified organisms. GMOs promise and may sometimes deliver greater short-term yields, but their real feature is in control over the cycle of agricultural production. GMOs lose reliability over successive generations, requiring farmers to purchase new seeds instead of relying on the plants’ own reproductive abilities. Contracts and patent laws often require seed repurchasing as well. GMOs may cross-pollinate with conventional crops and weeds, contaminating plant genomes and potentially creating herbicide-resistant “super weeds.” GMOs can be engineered to have sterile offspring to prevent gene flow, but sterile plants reinforce the same dependencies that drive the rift between farmers and their crops. The connection between the agricultural worker and their work is key to soil fertility and plant biodiversity, which “can only be maintained by creating the conditions for a genuine partnership between networks of farmers and agronomists who don't see plants as mere repositories of DNA, but as living beings that evolve over the years, adapting to the new conditions they encounter." 


Sustainable Agriculture and Socialism


Biodiversity is natural and essential for sustainable agriculture. It supports environmental adaptability and reduces weeds without the complicated additions and subtractions of intensive agriculture. But biodiversity doesn't fit well with capitalist agriculture, which demands uniform and fungible products with no variation so that their exchange value can reliably be realized. The quest for maximum returns on invested capital also demands the suppression of other life (i.e. weeds and pests) that can’t be profitably sold, even if that means taking shortcuts that destroy future fertility to boost the present.


But what are weeds and pests outside of their capitalist definition as unwanted organisms? Sometimes “weeds” and “pests” serve supporting biological and ecological roles. They may suppress other more destructive organisms, metabolize or make essential nutrients more available, and fertilize the soil. Once gone, their positive supporting role cannot be replaced without creating other negative consequences from inorganic chemical additions to the soil–herbicides and pesticides. These kill more than just "weeds" and "pests"–they also kill the microfauna at the root of humus formation and fertility, creating dependency on chemical fertilizers. Artificial fertilizers, in turn, promote more weed growth that then requires more herbicides to suppress. Fertilizers also create political dependency and vulnerability to global trade shocks as we’re likely to see later this year. Chemically fertilized soil is dying soil, requiring increasing chemical management to support ever-declining yields that inevitably fall below what a sustainably managed soil produces. 


Sustainably managed agriculture requires additional investment into soil science (pedology) and agricultural labor to maximize the long-term productivity of the soil. In general, it means reintroducing soil flora and fauna and avoiding practices that disrupt natural systems important to the structure and life of the soil. Sustainable farming reintroduces earthworms, mushrooms, and natural enemies of harmful insects. It avoids plowing, which buries, suffocates, and kills aerobic fungi that produce essential humic acids and return nutrients to soil. It also encourages systems and organisms to evolve together (including through epigenetics) to adapt to changing environmental conditions.


Only socialism can fully develop sustainable agroecology. Capitalist states are incapable of banning intensive agriculture and mobilizing the human, educational, scientific, and technical resources required for sustainable agroecology. Sustainable agroecology requires system-level planning of which only socialism is capable. Cuba, for example, makes political choices and creates economic rules (including markets) to implement them, without bowing to capitalist short-term interests in profitability. Capitalist countries have greater fear of capital flight, and their decisionmaking is constrained by institutions like the WTO, which prohibits investments and subsidies that sustainable agroecology requires.


Though socialism is a prerequisite for sustainable development, the transition takes time. Socialist development requires the controlled use of fossil fuels despite their ecological impacts. Socialist states must build up the forces of production enough to resist capitalist onslaught and to invest in alternative systems of energy and agriculture. Despite China’s massive production of inexpensive solar panels, Cuba can't switch to clean energy overnight and still depends on fossil fuels, especially in sectors like farm-to-city transportation where the green transition is more difficult. However temporary, socialist states' need for fossil fuels is a vulnerability: "this kind of interdependence...remains a fragile foundation for the Cuban economy, when a partner [then the USSR, now Venezuela] is lost to a pro-imperialist putsch..."


Socialist Science and Epigenetics


Dialectical materialism (socialist philosophy) helped Soviet scientists see beyond the idealist limitations in Western genetics and achieve practical results in agriculture, biology, and ecology, only recently recognized, albeit obliquely, in the rise of the science of epigenetics. 


Western genetics viewed evolution through natural selection as the only mechanism of evolution. They viewed genes as the fixed determinants of an organism’s characteristics and firmly rejected any suggestion that an organism’s environment could alter its characteristics, much less transmit those acquired characteristics to its offspring. In other words, the evolution of genes was a one-way street: from genes to characteristics, and never from characteristics to genes.


Western genetics took on its idealist form around the idea of “genes” decades before the discovery of DNA. It was closely related to eugenics–i.e., that genes determined an individual’s fitness (intelligence, health, social aptitude, etc.), that those genes could not change but through crude natural selection (survival of the fittest, culling of the weak), and that therefore those with “superior” genes (usually identified as white rich people in the North) should be encouraged to reproduce while those with “inferior” genes (poor brown people in the South) should be cut off from reproduction. Western geneticists thought they had found confirmation of their idealist suppositions in the discovery of DNA.


Soviet scientists studied dialectical materialism and tended to approach the natural world as a more dynamic and interconnected system with constantly accumulating contradictions and negations of seemingly stable forces. They were inclined to reject idealist concepts like fixed genes that unilaterally determined characteristics without being subject to any induced changes themselves except for the failure to reproduce. They therefore rejected Western genetics and pursued agricultural science on a relatively independent path, viewing soil and seeds not as fixed inert objects but as dynamic living material in flux and constantly evolving.


The path taken by Soviet scientists showed results in the form of improved agricultural yields, crop resilience, and the end of cyclical famines that had occurred for all prior history. They created the concept of “plant education,” whereby plants could be taught to endure certain environmental stresses and transmit those acquired traits to their offspring. Through “vernalization,” for example, wheat seeds artificially exposed to periods of freezing temperatures could survive post-germination spring freezes that previously led to crop failure in the field. Not only did the vernalized plants show more resilience, but so did their offspring. Soviet scientists (led by Lysenko) were ridiculed by Western geneticists for engaging in pseudoscience, and they were rightly criticized for dogmatically and undialectically rejecting Western genetics wholesale. But they achieved practical positive results at a time when Western genetics showed little utility outside of eugenics and suggested that Western genetics did not have all the answers or the final word. 


In the decades after the loss of the Soviet Union, the science of epigenetics has partially vindicated the work of Lysenko and the Soviet scientists. In short, we now understand that though organisms initially evolved to conserve the identity of their genes by preventing mutations, many organisms have evolved the ability to loosen their anti-mutation mechanisms in times of stress. It’s a very dialectical negation of the negation: an evolved tendency to preserve genetic identity is negated by an evolved counter-tendency to alter genetic identity under stressful conditions. Epigenetics allows organisms to evolve faster than strict natural selection would allow, by increasing the rate of mutations or by activating dormant sections of genetic code and passing along those activations into the next generations. Though epigenetic action is more common in plants (given their lack of mobility and inability to move out of stressful environments), it can be seen in humans too: descendants of women who lived through a famine in Holland in WWII inherited a tendency toward fat storage and obesity, which is disadvantageous outside of famine conditions.


Lessons from Socialist Developments in Agroecology


"As far as soil fertility and energy are concerned, resource limitations are an incentive for research, and humanity has always been able to overcome such limits, not thanks to capitalism, but rather in spite of it! Just as immigration is not responsible for structural unemployment, just as physicists' formulas are not responsible for the American bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, so technical and scientific progress is not responsible for the environmental damage caused by the best disguised class: the bourgeoisie. This is our common enemy!"


Suing cites several examples of agroecological successes, mostly from the Soviet Union and Cuba, that everyone interested in agroecology (i.e., anyone who eats food) should learn from. Here are some some highlights and useful concepts:

  • Since Cuba abandoned pesticides in the 1990s, Cuba has been a paradise for bees. Beehives yield twice the honey in Cuba as they do in France.

  • Intensive vs. extensive agriculture

    • Intensive: "doping" the soil and cultivated plants with pesticides, hormones, and chemical fertilizers to maximize yield; substitutes permanent chemical fertilization for the living soil. Can lead to out-of-control nitrate cycle: intensive pig farming -> excessive slurry application to cultivated soils -> growth of weeds (most are nitrophilic) -> use of pesticides -> contamination of waters -> "water so rich in nitrates that it is carcinogenic"

    • Extensive: not pumping yield over sustainable limits but cultivating larger areas and naturally increasing fertility of poor soil to its sustainable capacity.

  • Forest strips and agroforestry

    • Reintroduction of trees (the "masters of the soil") on or around fields improves water retention, creates wind breaks, protects against rain damage, replenishes soil and promotes cover cropping with falling plant matter, absorbs excess nitrates, promotes soil formation, draws minerals from rock into biological materials, and creates enormous biodiversity and biomass with no added fertilizers or pesticides.

  • Soil structure 

    • Soil structure is important for conserving water and keeping in place the mineral salts (natural fertilizers) that plants need. Plowing and soil compaction by heavy machinery disturb optimal soil structure and kill fungi that produce essential humic acids and return nutrients to soil.

    • Optimal soil structure is modeled on the forest floor: the most fertile soil, yet requiring no human additions.

    • Optimal soil structure requires a mixture of plants whose roots restructure the soil and enrich it as they degrade.

  • Polyculture vs. monoculture

    • Different species of plants protect their neighbors against pests, making pesticides unnecessary.

    • Monoculture exhausts the soil because it removes interdependent plant species that naturally regenerate the soil.

  • Agro-sylvo-pastoralism

    • "the rational and autonomous articulation of cultivation under plant cover, the use of trees (shelter from the elements, but also sources of lignin) and the use of livestock pastures (animals fed on cultivated grasses and producing slurry that can be reused for natural composts)."

  • Mulch

    • Soil texture must be protected to reduce erosion from water, wind, and evaporation.

    • Plant cover naturally regenerates the soil and protects soil texture.

    • Since the mid-1950s, intensive farming has replaced plant cover with plastic mulch, which is more profitable in the short term but pollutes soils with microplastics over the long term.


Another world is possible under socialism, and that world is reforested, biodiverse, mulchy, pesticide-free, and beautiful. We will once again be able to fully say the hills are alive!

Comments

  1. I hadn't really thought about the connections between socialism and capitalism with agriculture. Interesting read!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What I've been reading

Planter Fascist-itis: the Undead Evil of Confederates and Their Ilk