Unequal Exchange, Part 2
Review of Torkil Lauesen’s Unequal Exchange, continued from Part 1
As a concept, unequal exchange carries far more explanatory power for the dynamics of class struggle in the imperial core than false consciousness. There are real material reasons why workers in the Global North side with empire (or at least passively accept its predations on workers in the Global South) rather than act in solidarity and resist the capitalists that exploit Northern and Southern workers alike.
Lauesen posits that as long as a worker’s wages (measured by the value/embodied labor they can purchase with them) are less than the surplus value extracted from them through by capitalists, the worker is not an exploiter and has no material basis for antagonism with workers in other countries. But wages themselves can contain surplus value extracted from other workers in the form of underpriced commodities. When a worker’s wages contain more surplus value in this form than the surplus value extracted from the worker, the worker is a net exploiter whose material interests have shifted away from international solidarity.
The privilege an imperial worker enjoys through unequal exchange is the basis for labor aristocracy and social democracy. The privilege tends to shift the class struggle away from revolution and toward reform; away from anti-imperialism and toward a more favorable division of the spoils of empire. The privilege and its effects are the reason why the capitalist ruling class of the North has promoted social democracy to counteract communism, at least in Europe when the Soviet Union was next door with a competing worker-centered system that scared capitalists of its spread.
Lauesen estimates that for a worker in the U.S., the transition point at which their wage level turns them from net-exploited to a net-exploiter is $4 per hour. That struck me as too low. The federal minimum wage has been stuck at $7.25 per hour since 2009, and it’s not a livable wage. How could a starvation wage make a worker a net exploiter? I don’t know any worker in the U.S. who can live on $4 per hour and pay for necessities like housing, healthcare, and food. But the wage a worker needs to subsist and reproduce is not necessarily the same wage that makes the worker a net exploiter as Lauesen defines it. Lauesen defines a net exploiter as someone who receives more value via wages and consumption than the surplus value they produce through their own labor. A net exploiter might not be able to subsist and reproduce on their wages, but that doesn’t change the fact that they are net recipients of value through unequal exchange.
In the U.S., a worker who makes $15 per hour ($30,000 per year)--well over Lauesen’s transition point–will struggle to afford rent, food, and healthcare. Since the worker is receiving more value through wages and consumption than the surplus value they produce, why can’t the worker use that value to obtain a more comfortable standard of living? This worker, though technically a net exploiter, must pay for necessary commodities where they live–in the U.S., where monopolization and financialization have driven up the prices of life’s necessities. Large portions of each paycheck the worker receives go to capitalists who control these commodities and set their prices far above the cost of the labor needed to produce them. In estimating the transition point, Lauesen’s formula doesn’t take into account the surplus value that the worker produces in consumption–surplus value in the form of rent that a worker must pay to a landlord for housing. If we were to add to the surplus value side of Lauesen’s formula the surplus costs of rent and other necessary commodities whose prices are inflated far above their costs of production, the transition point would be higher. A worker may be able to buy 30 iPhones with their annual wages and thereby obtain far more embodied labor than the surplus value they themself produce in a year. But a worker needs housing, not 30 iPhones, and the capitalist extracts a lot of surplus value through rent. In other words, it’s important to consider what commodities a worker must purchase with their wages and what commodities a worker may purchase with their wages, and the differing levels of surplus value and embodied labor in each.
Still, to Lauesen’s credit, the power of the Northern worker’s wage, enhanced through unequal exchange, poses significant political implications regardless of the subsistence and reproduction costs of that worker. If unequal exchange were abolished, the power of the Northern worker’s wage would fall. Rent would take up an even larger portion of their paycheck, and the worker would be even more squeezed. The Northern worker who earns $15 per hour may yet be a net exploiter, but imperialism has positioned them so that they depend on the subsidy of value from Southern workers through unequal exchange. Take away the South’s subsidization of clothes and electronics, and the Northern worker will have to either buy less clothes and smartphones (gasp!) or make do with less money for other essentials like rent, food, and medicine. The system has been set up so that exploited workers in the North depend on exploiting other workers down the chain in the South. This dependency carries profound implications.
Northern workers above the transition point of net exploitation have material interests at odds with those of Southern workers. These Northern workers have an incentive to increase the value transfer of unequal exchange flowing from South to North, to enlarge the pot of imperial value rather than fight with their capitalist overlords for a larger relative share. Their efforts to enlarge the pot are much easier because capitalists have the same interests and will form labor-capital alliances to pursue them. This explains the involvement of the AFL-CIO (aka the AFL-CIA) in violently suppressing labor movements in the South, why U.S. dock workers refused to go on strike to stop the U.S. war on Vietnam, and why unions still refuse to strike to stop wars. On the ideological level, it also explains the unpopularity of anti-imperialism among workers in the North. This is what it means to have a “bourgeois proletariat”--a class of workers whose material interests and ideology tend to align more with their own capitalists than with other workers. It's why Engels was writing about how the proletariat in England was becoming increasingly bourgeoisified at the same time he was writing about their terrible living conditions. The condition of the Northern working class is bad, but it would be much worse without the massive subsidy from the South. Their immediate interests align with maintaining and expanding that subsidy–”trying to get a seat at a table that should be destroyed.”
But a bourgeoisified proletariat is not a stable formation. In the long run, it’s a class dependent on the exploitation of others who do not wish to be exploited and whose resistance cannot be held down forever. Its position of relative privilege over workers in other countries cannot last forever, and its alliance with capital is tenuous (see the erosion of social democracy in Europe since the fall of the Soviet Union). Though Northern workers’ immediate interests drive their support for U.S. empire, their long-term interests are becoming medium-term and their medium-term interests are becoming shorter. Looking beyond the short term, Northern workers have an interest in severing their own dependency on exploitation. Marx and Engels wrote that workers of the world have “nothing to lose but [their] chains” but Northern workers are bound by chains above and chains below, respectively binding Northern workers to capitalists and Southern workers to the North. These relations of dependency lead to dead ends for labor and ecology, as exploited peoples increasingly resist and nature increasingly “takes its revenge on us.” Workers in the North must lose their chains above and below to avoid sharing a fate with their empire. The Burgerreich must be destroyed; “the only way left…is to set fire to the capitalist stage.”
Unequal exchange and its political and ecological implications are dark, as in both concealed and disturbing. Workers in the North aren’t propagandized or brainwashed into supporting U.S. empire; they have an immediate stake in the South-North flows of value that the empire directs through unequal exchange. Many workers must be forced into short-term difficulty before becoming willing to struggle for their longer-term well-being as a class. Lauesen devotes a short chapter to ecological unequal exchange, with references to deeper analyses worth exploring.
Lauesen ends the book with chapters on resistance to unequal exchange and the transformation toward socialism. These chapters include some more hopeful material with an eye toward revolutionary developments, including China’s current role in reversing the advance of unequal exchange for the first time. Lauesen’s book is one of the most thought-provoking books I’ve read in the last year, and I highly recommend it to anyone interested in the often-hidden economic underpinnings of workers’ attitudes toward U.S. empire. For a shorter but equally engaging exposure to Lauesen’s thinking on unequal exchange, I highly recommend listening to the recent interview of Lauesen on the Rev Left Radio podcast.
Comments
Post a Comment