Unequal Exchange, Part 1

Why do people in the U.S. support imperialism, despite their professed moral objections to murder, theft, oppression, and all that imperialism entails? For the capitalist ruling class, material interests in maintaining and expanding the empire seem to explain it all. See Marco Rubio’s recent speech at the Munich Security conference, for example, where he openly promoted colonialism. They support imperialism because it’s obviously good for their class when U.S. companies gain markets, control resources, and exploit labor around the world. But what about us regular folk, people who need to work to live, and who are exploited by the same companies that exploit the world? Why are so many workers in the U.S. seemingly fine with their government funding the genocide in Palestine, kidnapping Venezuela’s president, blockading Cuba, and attacking Iran (to name the most recent examples), showing the world “why we don’t have healthcare”?

Some attribute pro-imperial attitudes of U.S. workers to “false consciousness,” a kind of mind trick the capitalist ruling class plays to get workers to adopt capitalist ideological positions as their own. Or more mildly, it’s just that our capitalist rulers get to determine which will be the ruling ideas, and they naturally choose ideas that favor their empire: “The ideas of the ruling class are in every epoch the ruling ideas.” This approach assumes that U.S. workers have no material interest in the maintenance and expansion of the U.S. empire–that the $1.5 trillion military budget would better serve U.S. national interests if redirected to healthcare, education, wages, etc. There’s truth in that position, but are U.S. workers really so dumb that they end up supporting U.S. imperialism anyway? Some certainly are. But is it all just a mind trick–or what material basis is there for pro-imperialist positions among U.S. workers? Marx also wrote that “[i]t is not the consciousness of men that determines their existence, but their social existence that determines their consciousness.” Could it be that many U.S. workers, liberals and conservatives alike, actually benefit from their empire (their social existence) and therefore favor their empire (their consciousness)?

I recently finished reading Unequal Exchange: Past, Present, and Future by Torkil Lauesen. Lauesen considers international trade through this materialist lens, with unequal exchange as the social existence (international exploitation through wage differences and the exchange of commodities) that shapes people’s consciousness (pro-imperial and anti-communist ideology). 

The concept of unequal exchange is fairly straightforward. Value comes from labor, and the value in commodities is embodied labor. Exploitation is a natural feature of capitalist production: workers sell their labor-power for one amount (wages) and create a higher amount of value (surplus value) which is appropriated by capitalists. But exploitation is not limited to the sphere of production. Exploitation–the under-compensated transfer of value from one group of persons to another–also occurs in exchange, when one group provides less value in exchange for more. Monthly Review’s lead article from January 2026 provides an excellent overview of the idea and its evolution, which spurred my interest in Lauesen’s book.

Unequal exchange is a feature of imperialism and a key reason for the durability of U.S. empire since the Second World War. It has three main bases that distort local prices of labor-power (despite an internationally consistent value): (1) suppression of labor movements in the periphery, (2) restrictions on the international movement of labor, and (3) rising wages in the imperial core through trade union struggles. The distortion of prices in international trade results in a massive transfer of value from the periphery to the core, reflected in the pricing of commodities at less than the value of the labor embodied in them. This “dark value” enjoyed by the buyer of an iPad, for example, is at least $472. The core annually imports 906 billion hours of embodied labor from the periphery, while exporting only 80 billion hours in return. The periphery contributes 90% of labor in global production but gets only 44% of global income, and workers in the periphery end up with less than half of their national share (21% of global income).

Lauesen spends the first three chapters reviewing the history of unequal exchange as an idea, its basic mechanics, and its measurement. The more challenging parts of the book, especially chapter 4, address the political implications of unequal exchange, which are what I’ll talk about in the next parts of my review.

Comments

  1. Thanks for sharing this--I don't think i'd ever read it myself, so i'll follow along to hear your thoughts and summary. The longer i live in this world, the harder it seems to divest myself from the system that materially exploits and curtails the livelihoods of 99.9% of the planet, animals and plants included.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for following along :) I totally agree -- individual divestment is practically impossible, though it can help build consciousness toward systemic change. A new world is struggling to be born!

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Hills Were Alive: Capitalist Suppression of Agroecology

What I've been reading

Planter Fascist-itis: the Undead Evil of Confederates and Their Ilk