America, América: Eulogizing Social Democracy Under the Settler Empire

Settler America has doomed social-democratic América. Is another América possible?

On paper, the ingredients for post-colonial social democracy are there. The hemisphere is rich in material resources. It birthed anti-colonial revolutions that shattered the Spanish empire. Its nation-states were forged with constitutions that profess to protect the rights and wellbeing of their citizens, and it has produced some of the most advanced conceptions of human rights. The very first constitution to enshrine a slate of social rights—the right to healthcare, education, a dignified life, and labor organizing—was Mexico’s in 1917. Yet, for 200 years, these possibilities have been subsumed by the gravitational pull of the largest and most successful settler empire in history. Like a black hole for progress, the United States doesn't just intervene; it bends the time and space of every nation within its reach, warping their historical arcs toward its own relentless accumulation and control over the hemisphere's labor and resources. Greg Grandin's America, América is an ambitious attempt to map this historical gravity, to lay out the tragic record of a promise perpetually deferred.

The book's great strength lies in its meticulous presentation of the premise. Across 50 chapters in 750+ pages covering 500 years, Grandin builds the historical case for social democracy in the Americas. He traces a lineage from the brutal colonial oppression of the Spanish—and the early humanist protest of Bartolomé de las Casas—through the independence movements of Gran Colombia. The Spanish conquest was a catastrophe, inaugurating history's "largest human mortality event in proportion to the global population." But it also provoked a "near century-long process of obsessive moral introspection" among Spanish clergy and jurists, a revolution in ethical thought that produced "an acknowledgment, at least as official policy if not practice, that Native Americans were humans, all humans were equal, and no one was born a 'natural slave'." This moral crisis, Grandin argues, laid the foundation for a more capacious republican tradition. On conquest, where the US Declaration of Independence is mute or worse—inverting settler-Native violence with a slur, “merciless Indian savages”—Venezuela's independence manifesto acknowledged that the new nation was built on stolen land. Simón Bolívar himself declared that the Conquest was “impure,” shrouded in the “black mantle of crime,” and that liberation required “atonement” for the “annihilated Indians” and their descendants. This is the foundation upon which Grandin suggests a more humane society could have been built.

Grandin builds a narrative of the systematic, devastating, violent thwarting of social progress. In contrast to the Spanish, English settlers "experienced something different. They came on their ships thinking of the ancients, imagining themselves the new Adam, the new Noah, the new Moses, leading the chosen into an empty—or empty enough—Canaan." The Anglo-American project was defined by evasion and denial, reviving the doctrines of discovery and conquest and staking out hard and narrow individual rights that stood in stark opposition to the Latin American tradition of social rights. The result was slavery in its most brutal form, a system of racialized underdevelopment, and endless meddling, interventions, and coups. The US, Grandin shows, conceived its own exceptionalism and its right to endlessly expand. This forced its Latin American neighbors to develop a new, cooperative conception of international law in an attempt to contain it—a conception that shaped the modern international legal system and gave rise to some of its most ambitious humanitarian aspects.

However, while Grandin is a masterful historian, he offers no more than a eulogy for a project that was doomed from the start. His tragic recounting of social democracy in América should not be mistaken for revolutionary analysis. He roots for the losers, which makes for a compelling narrative but lacks a model for change. The answer to the question of social democracy's failure can't just be that the settler empire to the north keeps killing social-democratic governments—that simplistic answer may ring truer for Mexico, “so far from God and so close to the US,” but it evades a deeper, more uncomfortable truth: social democracy is compromised from the start. A politics adequate to the circumstances of América requires organizational forms capable of overcoming the dominance of the American settler empire. To expect social democracy, an ideology committed to maintaining the social dominance of capital, to accomplish this is to expect a wolf to guard the sheep.

Grandin's own narrative betrays a problematic favoritism toward social-democratic moments, however fleeting and unsuccessful. This leads him to an unjustified antagonism toward more revolutionary developments. He glosses over the Haitian Revolution, the first and only successful large-scale uprising by enslaved people, neutrally referring to the “terrors” and “race war” that followed French and US efforts to reimpose their colonial fetters. He handwaves away communist-led states, even when durable and materially successful, by labeling them "authoritarian"—a lazy epithet for Cuba and a gross mischaracterization of China. Most revealingly, he fails to recognize the communitarian social forms emerging from the Bolivarian revolution in Venezuela, ignoring the comunas, perhaps the most enduring and democratic aspect of that project. This reveals the core contradiction: Grandin's political imagination is captive to the very liberal framework he critiques.

So, do the premises laid out in America, América support an ongoing historical case for social democracy? No. They show, with heartbreaking clarity, its structural failure, caused not just by Yankee bullets but by its own inherent contradictions and insufficiency. The professed goals of social democracy—welfare, inclusion, dignity—are wonderful, and it is right to mourn their devastation. But as an ideology under the umbrella of liberalism, social democracy is compromised to its core. Its compromise with capitalism is not a tactical error; it is a fundamental feature. That compromise is the engine that drives all the tragedies Grandin so eloquently elucidates. He is great at laying out the premises, but his own analysis demonstrates that social democracy was not simply betrayed; it also betrayed itself to a large extent. 

Perhaps a deep and durable Américan revolution is impossible under the shadow of the settler empire. But even that tragic supposition is insufficient to convert the sorrows of history into a prescription for more of the same. Though Grandin writes a powerful history of defeat, the promise of social democracy was structurally compromised from the start. What’s needed and missing in Grandin’s book is a structurally sound model for liberation: one capable of not only resisting acute imperialist attacks but also containing the chronic power of foreign capital and its domestic allies. Unfortunately, America, América elides or even puts down the few attempts at such a model—Haiti, Cuba, Venezuela, China—even when they have made unparalleled advances and held onto their gains far longer than their feeble social-democratic peers held onto reforms. He dismisses them as “authoritarian” while mourning the defeated. Grandin is a eulogist looking back, not a revolutionary looking forward. For a liberatory future of América, we must look to the latter.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Hills Were Alive: Capitalist Suppression of Agroecology

What I've been reading

Planter Fascist-itis: the Undead Evil of Confederates and Their Ilk