Wealth and Its Possession: Reading The Pearl by John Steinbeck

"This pearl is like sin! It will destroy us." — Juana, in John Steinbeck's The Pearl


Most readings of The Pearl*—especially the ones taught in schools—treat it as a parable about greed as an individual vice. That reading betrays the text. Steinbeck's novella is not a warning against wanting too much; it is an indictment of a social order that makes basic needs unattainable without unbearable violence. The capitalist social order is always-already violent, and erupts into violence between individuals who seek to overcome it.


What did Kino do wrong? The individual lessons one might take away seem meaningless: avoid wealth, cash out when you can even if you're getting ripped off, or at least surrender your wealth before it drives you to murderous ruin.


The standard lesson of "don't be greedy" rings hollow because Kino was not greedy—he was exploited and poor. The doctor wouldn't care for his family when Kino had no wealth—that refusal was the ordinary violence of the order; the pearl only made it visible. And once Kino got the pearl, the doctor gave the baby “medicine” that made the baby sicker, then “cured” that sickness for a fee. He poisoned Kino's child so he could bill Kino for the antidote. The priest and the pearl buyers likewise acted to get their cuts of the pearl, to which they were respectively entitled by religion and by the law of the market.


Nor was Kino greedy in the sense of wanting too much. He wanted an education for his son, clothes for his family, a church wedding with Juana, and a rifle.


The Pearl takes the form of an individualistic moral parable, but its content is that of a social tragedy. Like The Grapes of Wrath, written around the same time and in the same context of the Great Depression, The Pearl is a story about social crisis and its manifestations among the lower classes.


The Possession of Wealth: Wealth's Possession of Its Possessor


The closest thing to an individual lesson is the inversion of wealth and its possessor—but even that is a lesson about a social relation, not a personal vice. Marx wrote that the capitalist is "capital personified and endowed with consciousness and a will"—the possessor of wealth becomes the agent of a logic larger than himself, his "subjective aim" nothing but the expansion of value for its own sake. Kino finds the pearl, but only because the scorpion found Coyotito. Kino buries it, guards it, attacks his wife for it, and even kills for it. Does Kino control the pearl or does the pearl control Kino? Juana sees it first: "This pearl is like sin! It will destroy us." The pearl is a fetish—a thing that seems to have power over people, but actually reflects the power of the social relations (i.e., poverty and the drive to escape it) that it mediates. The pearl seems to exercise a magical power over Kino and others around him. But there’s no magic–just the power of the market and the colonial order that determines who gets crushed (the indigenous) and who gets to escape (the doctor, to Paris). 


Kino Was Not Greedy But Poor


It was not greed but his desire to escape poverty that drove Kino to kill. What he wanted was modest, not extravagant luxury: an education for his son, new clothing for his family and himself, the church's blessing, and a rifle. Perhaps excepting the rifle (the only one of his desires that was fulfilled in the end), Kino wanted the minimum markers of dignity. He didn't want the doctor's house, the priest's authority, or the pearl buyers' salaries. The tragedy isn't that Kino wanted too much—it's that the social order made even these small things impossible without violence. And even with violence (embodied in the rifle), Kino does not escape his condition. He no longer has a son to educate. The only dream he realizes is the instrument of his son's death. The promises of individual wealth are no solution to the social condition of poverty.


The Social Lesson: What Would Have to Change?


The more coherent reading of The Pearl and more meaningful lesson is social: we need to create a society where we can trust our doctors to heal us without the distorting incentives of money, where we can send our children to school without worrying about the cost, where cultural necessities like marriage and even baptism are not sites of economic exploitation, where the prospects for a full and decent life are not so remote as to make wealth worth killing for to obtain or protect.


Steinbeck shows every institution—medicine, religion, commerce, education—as a site of extraction. The doctor heals only for payment; the priest blesses only to remind Kino of his duty; the pearl buyers conspire to cheat him. The novel's indictment isn't that Kino was foolish to want wealth or vicious for trying to protect it. The villain is the social order that made Kino's modest desires into a death sentence—particularly that of a Mexican town bearing the marks of colonialism, inequality, and a de facto caste system that continually dispossessed indigenous people like Kino.


Coyotito's Death and the Return of the Pearl


If The Pearl's thesis is social and not individual, what should we make of the ending, where Juana refuses the pearl and leaves it to Kino to throw back? On an individual level, wealth's possession over Kino could not be undone by anyone but Kino himself; Juana, the story's moral anchor, seems to understand that wealth taken away does not have the same effect as wealth surrendered. On a social level, I read it as a suggestion that social problems must have social solutions, not individual endowments that allow lucky ones to escape shared conditions. By throwing away the pearl, Kino is throwing away escapism, having seen escape was no different than exile and that he couldn't escape with his son.


Unlike the ending of The Pearl, the folk tale that inspired Steinbeck had a happy ending: Coyotito laughed, threw the pearl back, and found freedom in poverty. The folk tale romanticized poverty, and Steinbeck did well to change it into a tragedy. As Steinbeck knew, writing in the Great Depression, poverty in the midst of abundance is unacceptable. In The Grapes of Wrath he had already shown what that looks like: 

Carloads of oranges dumped on the ground. The people came for miles to take the fruit, but this could not be. How would they buy oranges at twenty cents a dozen if they could drive out and pick them up? And men with hoses squirt kerosene on the oranges, and they are angry at the crime, angry at the people who have come to take the fruit. A million people hungry, needing the fruit—and kerosene sprayed over the golden mountains.

A poor person unable to obtain the basics of life is in no sense free.


The Meaning of the Pearl


The pearl does not stand for greed, but for poverty and what it does to social relations. Poverty and its negation (wealth) open Kino and his family to exploitation—to the doctor's poison and costly cure, to the priest's demand for a tithe, and to the pearl buyers' attempt to seize Kino's surplus. Poverty, not greed, drives Kino to protect his illusory path to individual escape. Poverty, inversely mirrored in the pearl, leads Kino to kill four men in defense of his prospective escape and simultaneously results in the attainment of one of his desires (possession of a rifle) and in the death of all he wanted to protect (Coyotito). The answer lies not in the acquisition of winning lottery tickets (which can inflict pearl-like destructive effects on their possessors) or the tossing of such tickets into the sea, but in the creation of a society where no one needs to dive for pearls or buy lottery tickets to get a chance to get by. The greed reading doesn't just miss the point; it reverses it, blaming Kino for the violence the social order visits upon him.

_____

*I was prompted by one of my favorite podcasters, Breht O'Shea of Rev Left Radio, to get back into reading John Steinbeck, one of my long-time favorite authors, through this book. The Pearl is worth reading. It shouldn't take more than a few hours. I won't summarize the book here since I'm writing for myself and my 2.5 readers, who have read The Pearl or can spare the small investment required to read it.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Hills Were Alive: Capitalist Suppression of Agroecology

What I've been reading

Planter Fascist-itis: the Undead Evil of Confederates and Their Ilk