Monthly Monthly Review Review (April 2026)

Here’s my monthly review of the April 2026 issue of Monthly Review.

Notes from the Editors

  • We’re crossing several irreversible tipping points in the ecological crisis caused by capitalism, and the forces of reaction have led us into a period of ecofascism. “At present, when reform has proven impossible and a deadly reaction has set in, the revolutionary reconstitution of society at large, based on a resurgent eco-egalitarian movement for substantive democracy and sustainable human development, is the only real alternative to capitalist exterminism.” 


Vijay Prashad, The Idea of the "Uyghur Genocide" and the Realities of Xinjiang

  • I enjoyed Prashad’s article on capitalism and colonialism in last month’s Monthly Review (reviewed here), but his article in this month’s issue is a clunker. He examines the history behind the thousands of terror attacks that China’s Xinjiang province has suffered since 1990 and the background of sketchy U.S.-backed terror groups like the East Turkistan Islamic Movement. He also highlights some of China’s accomplishments in lifting Xinjiang out of poverty. But his kind of dry historical analysis is much weaker than a more direct, critical analysis of the propaganda itself. The article has a bizarre, wishy-washy conclusion: that China’s developmental approach to Xinjiang is depoliticized and inadequate to address “the lack of understanding and the lack of trust across populations.” Prashad doesn’t explain in any concrete terms how China’s holistic approach is “depoliticized” or what his insinuations of depoliticization and distrust have to do with combatting the U.S.’s false accusations of genocide against China. He ends his article with an ambivalent shrug: “What this [his vaguely alternative “politicized” approach] will come to mean in practice is not easy to imagine.” Yeah, I can’t imagine what he’s talking about either.

  • Skip Prashad’s Xinjiang article and read Roderic Day’s article instead. It’s five years old but presents a much stronger critical takedown of the U.S.’s false accusations against China. Day dissects the propaganda and exposes their sources, tracing them back to anticommunism, antisemitism/Sinophobia, and imperialism (as opposed to Prashad’s tracing the political history of Xinjiang back to the dynastic kingdoms of China–what for?). I can’t sufficiently recommend Day’s article and his writing in general. 

    • If you just want to know what the basic facts are about Xinjiang and U.S. accusations against China, here is Day’s summary, which fully checks out with all I’ve read on the topic:

  1. The rise of Xi Jinping and the Belt & Road Initiative posed a serious challenge to American supremacy much earlier than they were expecting, so 

  2. the U.S. amped up their funding of terrorism in the region, as per the “Afghan Trap” doctrine outlined by Brzezinski, but 

  3. instead of sending in the PLA, repeating the error of the Soviets, China reacted by building schools and vocational programs instead. 

  4. As a result, the U.S. and its allies desperately pivoted to accusing them of “genocide,” despite lack of evidence. 


Yinhao Zhang, The Material Basis of a Spectre: Why China's Youth Are Rediscovering Mao

  • Mao is gaining popularity among students and recent graduates from China’s top universities, not because of a top-down propaganda campaign but despite a state-led effort to deemphasize some of the more radical aspects of Mao’s thought, specifically the period from 1949 to 1957. “Mao fever” is “a movement that has emerged and endured independently of state direction,” “a spontaneous, powerful ideological current from below that is actively clashing with the postreform liberal consensus–a worldview that rejected revolutionary politics and embraced Western-style market reforms and values.”

  • Zhang attributes the rise of Mao fever in part to the end of rapid economic expansion. As younger generations enter the workforce, they are encountering fiercer competition and finding opportunities harder to come by. With a national hero like Mao, it’s easy to see why students admire his “immense contributions: establishing a sovereign nation, driving industrialization, fighting imperialism and colonialism, advancing women’s liberation and mass literacy, combating bureaucracy, and pursuing social justice.” More generally, Chinese youth are “beginning to deconstruct the official verdict” on the Cultural Revolution, which has been criticized by the CPC since shortly after it concluded. They’re seeing the Cultural Revolution not as “a decade of chaos and catastrophe,” but as “a necessary struggle against the new ruling class.”

  • China hawks and haters shouldn’t get too excited about that last line about “struggle against the new ruling class.” The youth seeking to reclaim that struggle are not looking to be used as pawns in a new attempt at a color revolution like the 1989 Tiananmen protests; they are “widely considered the most patriotic and pro-Party generation since the reform era began.” They have seen what China’s CPC-led state can do for poverty alleviation, environmental remediation, and technological breakthroughs. They are aware of the New Cold War that the U.S. is waging on China and the importance of standing up to Western aggression and threats to China’s sovereignty. They are nationalist and anti-imperialist, seeking to hold their country true to its founding revolutionary socialist principles. “Mao will not go away” and China’s “revolutionary agenda, it seems, remains unfinished.” (For an open-ended conclusion, “remains unfinished” is much better than “not easy to imagine”--I’m still getting over Prashad’s stinker.)


Michael Viola, Yellow Shades upon a Global Color Line

  • Good example of why anti-racism is empty without anti-imperialism: 

the strategies to “Stop Anti-Asian Hate” were largely dissociated from the history of U.S. military and colonial interventions in Asia and the capitalist exploitation of Asian bodies. As a result, the dominant strategies to “Stop Anti-Asian Hate” reproduced what Fanon warned us against and what was alluded to in the opening paragraph of this essay: the evasion of U.S. military and economic imperialism that generally makes possible and legitimizes anti-Asian racism.

  • And the necessity of connecting the U.S. war on immigrants to the U.S. wars on their countries of origin:

U.S. imperialism in its most current phase is frantically seeking its survival through gunboat diplomacy, threats of annexing foreign lands, and further dragging the Philippines into a New Cold War with China. The existing apparatus for such global maneuverings historically directed toward the foreign other is rapidly being turned inward on U.S. populations, undocumented or otherwise, as we witness the mass detention, disappearance, and destruction of people of all colors.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Hills Were Alive: Capitalist Suppression of Agroecology

What I've been reading

Planter Fascist-itis: the Undead Evil of Confederates and Their Ilk